Comments on: LGR Reviews The Sims 4 Realm of Magic https://simsvip.com/2019/09/27/lgr-reviews-the-sims-4-realm-of-magic/ Sims 4 News and Game Guides Fri, 25 Sep 2026 00:33:00 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=4.9.8 By: Pamela https://simsvip.com/2019/09/27/lgr-reviews-the-sims-4-realm-of-magic/#comment-744986 Wed, 02 Oct 2019 17:11:00 +0000 http://simsvip.com/?p=121687#comment-744986 As someone who was beyond excited for witches and everything related, I was so disappointed with this pack. There are aspects I liked, but it is missing so many elements and there really isn’t much unique or fun about it. I hate to bring the sims 3 into it, but the supernatural pack for TS3 did witches so much better. And that pack has several other life states besides witches to make content for. Everything from CAS to build/buy and especially gameplay is just lacking in this pack.

]]>
By: Dove https://simsvip.com/2019/09/27/lgr-reviews-the-sims-4-realm-of-magic/#comment-744978 Wed, 02 Oct 2019 14:53:00 +0000 http://simsvip.com/?p=121687#comment-744978 I agree with all of your assessments! (Ha ha, and I re-watched the Katy Perry Sweet Treats review awhile ago. Still amusingly savage and spot-on, though I never had that pack.)

I rewatched Carl’s Island Living video to see what you were referring to specifically and at the very beginning he mentions that he never really does reviews but a couple people asked for his opinion, which is why he made a video review, so that’s probably a major factor as well. LGR has been reviewing for a long time and is very good at talking casually to the viewer about his opinions. He sounds charming and Carl doesn’t, particularly when Carl started off with a list (he was going over bullet points to explain his conclusion at the end but it’s still a little grating.)

As for the quote, he follows that up by saying it’s not that he feels that his desire should force you to level up mermaids and play the same way that he does but he does say it a bit off-putting and doesn’t follow-through the thought fully. He was trying to say he’s not the kind of player who feels his way is the best way but then that ended up being exactly what he said. His next line is about how the mermaids need to be differentiated in some way, and that’s his real beef with the situation regardless of which way you prefer (starting out powerful or having to work for it slowly) which I can agree with to some extent.

I think that was his main complaint about the spell-casters too since they did follow a system that’s a bit closer to vampires. I think his issue was that it’s easy to buy all of the perks if you really focus on it and most of them are simply for making the grind less of a grind, so it feels like the spell-casters are all the same too unless you only focus on one style of magic. The spells are randomly gotten so you could only talk to a specific sage and maybe only focus on dueling them or getting training from them or only buy tomes from that specific branch. Considering how much down-time there is between directly asking for a spell and how boring just practicing is, you’ll likely branch out into cauldrons too. And it’s hard to force yourself to avoid that because the potions are quite powerful, experimenting in the cauldron gives you more options, plus it’s another spell you can get from the sages while you’re waiting for the cool-down to go away.

The only way to soften this blow would be to focus on other areas like a job, family, and socializing which would help but I feel like many people would be going into it to focus solely on the occult so it entirely depends on your Sim and if you have the willpower to pick a branch and stick with it. Even if you wanted to create a magic school of your own, along the line of Hogwarts, it would only work and be interesting if you were building up the teachers who would build the school themselves, which takes planning and foresight. I think that means it’s possible to have fun with it but it’s really on the player to enjoy the newest features and they have to know what they want and how to get it.

Carl’s overall complaint with IL was that an expansion, for the price that they are, should have more depth and replay value, with a stronger affect on other worlds outside of Sulani and he said that’s why he didn’t knock Strangerville for this same issue. However, I think he basically ends up knocking RoM for that same reason. I think it does go back to spell-casters having less nuance than vampires do, so I feel the problem is that it managed to tick off even more boxes with the new occult. And yeah, you can probably distinguish your spell-caster but I feel like you’d have to force it rather than it happening in an organic way (players are inclined to dabble when it comes to something new and his criticism about early burnout isn’t wrong.)

I think the problem with Carl’s videos is inexperience and well, his overall tone… some people are just a pleasure to listen to and others aren’t. Perhaps he could improve this with effort but I don’t know; maybe he can’t. I guess we’ll find out. XD

Although maybe I’m reading too much into all of this.

]]>
By: Dove https://simsvip.com/2019/09/27/lgr-reviews-the-sims-4-realm-of-magic/#comment-744976 Wed, 02 Oct 2019 13:45:00 +0000 http://simsvip.com/?p=121687#comment-744976 I feel your frustrations but I’m a tiny bit confused about why you’re paying off a birthday gift… unless you meant it was a gift to yourself? 🙂

]]>
By: Dove https://simsvip.com/2019/09/27/lgr-reviews-the-sims-4-realm-of-magic/#comment-744975 Wed, 02 Oct 2019 13:36:00 +0000 http://simsvip.com/?p=121687#comment-744975 Edit: Never mind, I just read the other comments. lol Sorry! XD

]]>
By: SimsVIP https://simsvip.com/2019/09/27/lgr-reviews-the-sims-4-realm-of-magic/#comment-744958 Tue, 01 Oct 2019 22:16:00 +0000 http://simsvip.com/?p=121687#comment-744958 Beth, your comment was approved. Sometimes the spam filter sees larger messages as “spam” for whatever reason. I blame Disqus. 🙂

]]>
By: Joanna Sebastian https://simsvip.com/2019/09/27/lgr-reviews-the-sims-4-realm-of-magic/#comment-744936 Tue, 01 Oct 2019 12:24:00 +0000 http://simsvip.com/?p=121687#comment-744936 Don’t feel bad I own a windows 10 hp computer 64 and my friend owns a asus 800 dollar laptop and which is a windows 10 64 one tb computer and her computer can run it, but I own a 1200 dollar laptop and it can’t even run it anymore so I wasted on every package close to 1,000 dollars and I just bought a playstation 4. I ain’t playing the computer version I own a playstation 4 so I can only play on the playstation because I don’t have millions of dollars to buy a new laptop when I just got a Samsung Galaxy s10 for my birthday in July. So I am broke until this phone is paid off.

]]>
By: Scarlet https://simsvip.com/2019/09/27/lgr-reviews-the-sims-4-realm-of-magic/#comment-744915 Tue, 01 Oct 2019 00:26:00 +0000 http://simsvip.com/?p=121687#comment-744915 Hi Beth. Your comments weren’t blocked, they’re just in the queue for moderation. Disqus throws them in Pending when certain words are used. I don’t see anything wrong with your comments, so I’m sure Alexis will approve them when she gets time.

]]>
By: Sparkie Monkey https://simsvip.com/2019/09/27/lgr-reviews-the-sims-4-realm-of-magic/#comment-744909 Mon, 30 Sep 2019 20:46:00 +0000 http://simsvip.com/?p=121687#comment-744909 Yeah, that was an ugly series of commenting. I just assume that’s why they’re watching the comment section more closely.

]]>
By: Anne-tione https://simsvip.com/2019/09/27/lgr-reviews-the-sims-4-realm-of-magic/#comment-744908 Mon, 30 Sep 2019 20:00:00 +0000 http://simsvip.com/?p=121687#comment-744908 A lot of people showed their true colors under that post. I personally don’t blame them for not wanting to attached that to their site.

]]>
By: Sparkie Monkey https://simsvip.com/2019/09/27/lgr-reviews-the-sims-4-realm-of-magic/#comment-744907 Mon, 30 Sep 2019 17:08:00 +0000 http://simsvip.com/?p=121687#comment-744907 I’ve had a few things get blocked recently. I think they’re trying to put fires out before they start after the muslim clothing post blew up and way out of proportion.

]]>